Some definitions Used by the Core
Group
A point, which very quickly became apparent to the Core
Group and is also noted in several of the Working Group reports (See A5.1, C1.2, C4.2,
D2.5), is the importance of a common use of terms. The Core Group therefore offers the
following definitions of its own understandings of key phrases.
The words 'homosexual'
and 'heterosexual' refer to mutual sexual attraction
between persons of the same sex and the opposite sex respectively. These words were
originally adjectives; now they are very often used also as nouns, a usage which the Core
Group regrets, since it may imply that this is the most important fact about a person's
identity. The word 'gay' was chosen by homosexual persons to describe themselves in the
1960s, as a positive adjective in place of the earlier use of 'queer'. Originally 'gay'
was applied to both men and women; more recently it has been applied to men, and the older
term 'lesbian' (based on descriptions in the poetry of Sappho from Lesbos in
ancient Greece) is used exclusively for homosexual women. The term 'bisexual'
refers to someone who is sexually attracted to persons of both sexes.
'Sexuality' was originally defined narrowly as a
general description of sexual behaviour (and this narrow sense is used in many Anglican
documents, particularly the statement and resolutions of the 1998 Lambeth Conference).
However, today it is usually used more broadly to describe the whole way of reacting to
the world as a male or female. As such it reflects attitudes which are as much conditioned
by society and culture as by biology, if not more so. This latter sense is the one in
which it has been used in the discussions within the United Reformed Church since 1993.
A 'sexual relationship' refers to intimate sexual
contact between two people involving either penetrative sexual intercourse or mutual
genital stimulation. From such a point of view the term 'active sexual relationship'
is tautologous, since sexual relationships have been defined as 'active'; but this is also
the sense in which the word 'practice' is used with 'homosexual' or 'heterosexual'
as an adjective. It should be noted that the words 'active' and 'passive'
are also often used to denote respectively the partner who takes the initiative in
intercourse and the one who responds.
A distinction is often made between 'sexual orientation'
and 'sexual practice'. In this case 'orientation' refers to inclinations and
attitudes without the expression of these inclinations and attitudes in sexual activity. 'Sexual
practice' refers to sexual intimacy, as described above. Some have argued that this
distinction is artificial: in the view of the Core Group and several other Churches to
whom we have talked, this distinction is vital. This would be particularly so if we were
considering the position of bisexual persons, since in our view, if a bisexual orientation
were to lead to simultaneous homosexual and heterosexual relationships, this would
necessarily involve being unfaithful to one or more partners. 'Abstinence' refers
to the deliberate refraining from particular acts or activities. 'Celibacy' refers
to a vocation to live a single life in which one's sexuality is fulfilled in other ways
than by sexual activity or relationships.
Core
Group Report
Members:
Revd Malcolm Hanson, Revd Graham Maskery, Mrs Val Morrison, Dr David Thompson and Revd
Elizabeth Welch (Convener). The Revd Tony Burnham, General Secretary, served as secretary
to the Group.
1. PROLOGUE
1.1 The Core Group began the work of drafting this
report in the season of Epiphany, January 1999.
1.2 With the Magi, we were drawn in wonder and
adoration to Jesus, the Light of the World. We prayed for his presence to bring light to
our path as we journeyed together along the particular road to which we had been set. We
sought to bring the gifts of our work to give him honour.
1.3 We gathered conscious of people from across the
church surrounding us with their thoughts and prayers. As we reflected together, so we
grew in awareness of the commitment to the Lord throughout the church and the mutual
concern to share his light throughout the world.
1.4 We recognised that within this commitment to
mission which is at the heart of the church's life, people hold a very wide range of views
on a variety of issues. In their response to the Gospel and in their obedience to the one
Lord, some would call us to a renewed sense of faithfulness to a traditional understanding
of the biblical witness, while others would seek to challenge us to new understanding and
inclusivity in the light of contemporary knowledge.
1.5 Within
the one church, we acknowledge the variety of gifts and callings that are held and want to
affirm the importance of holding these together, that the one Lord may be served.
1.6 We look for a spirituality that sustains us in our diversity, praying
that, as the one Lord draws us to himself, so we may be drawn closer to one another in
ways that take us beyond our differences.
1.7As we
approach the turn of the Millennium, so we look back over 2000 years of joy and turmoil
that have accompanied Christian obedience. As we look forward to the coming Millennium, so
we place our trust again in the one God, Father, Son and Holy Spirit, who ever calls us to
faithfulness and new obedience.