|
book Reviews

Religious
Foundations of Western Civilization
ed Jacob Neusner. Pub Abingdon Press/Alban Books, pp600, ISBN 0-687-33202-8,
£19.99
In discussions on
the relationship between religion and culture it is often assumed
Christianity and Western civilization are coterminous. Theologians from
Africa and Asia remind us that the Christianity found in the Western
world should not be seen as the only valid form of the religion; it is
also a mistake to see Christianity as the only religion that has
influenced the development of Western Civilization. Judaism and, to a
lesser extent, Islam, have played an important part. This is a matter of
historical record.
But it is all too
easy to lapse into a sloppy piece of inter faith advocacy that
overstates other religions contribution at the expense of Christianity;
as one finds for example in some commentaries on the period when Spain
was under Muslim rule.
Religious
Foundations of Western Civilization is not such a book: it is a balanced
and fair study of the subject that should be on the reading list of
every student of theology or indeed anyone who cares deeply about the
past, present and future of our society. The book is a collection of
articles on a range of issues by distinguished scholars in the field.
After an initial
introduction the articles are divided into five sections: ‘Religions of
the West’; ‘Historical Common Interests’; ‘Historical Encounters’;
‘Modernity and the West: Negotiating Change’; and ‘Religion and Western
Civilization in the Twenty-First Century’. At the end of each article
are questions for discussion which not only assist the thinking around
the subject but also make the book a useful resource for group work.
Of course these
are huge subject areas and each essay gives only an introduction to the
subject, but this book would be a useful starting point for anyone
wishing to explore these matters in more detail. What makes the book
particularly useful is that it gives a very broad account of the nature
of the inter-religious encounter covering theology, philosophy,
spirituality, history and politics.
One could not
expect a single book to be exhaustive on this vast subject and, if one
wanted to be churlish, one could complain about the absence of a
detailed study of the role of trade in communicating different religious
ideas or the way the three faiths have impacted on each other
(positively and negatively) through art, music and literature. But these
omissions are not a serious criticism and do not detract from praise for
this important and indispensable study.
PC
PC
|